Sally’s Apple Crumb Pie

Servings: 5 Total Time: 2 hrs Difficulty: Intermediate
Serve this super tasty apple crumb pie for the holidays
View Gallery 1 photo

I’ve been making this pie for decades and it is always a huge hit every time I make it.

My favorite apples to use are Paula Reds but they are hard to find. Next up are Cortlands then

If they are not available I’ll use MacIntosh apples.

First Published in the King Arthur Flour’s Catalogue in 1993 see original below with photo of Sally and her daughter Jenna

Sally’s Apple Crumb Pie

Difficulty: Intermediate Prep Time 20 mins Cook Time 70 mins Rest Time 30 mins Total Time 2 hrs
Cooking Temp: 350  F Servings: 5
Best Season: Suitable throughout the year

Description

You will get rave reviews when you make this pie!!

Ingredients

Crust

Filling

Topping

Instructions

Assembling the pie

  1. Peel, core and slice apples thin

  2. add the rest of the filling ingredients and stir together gently

    Let the apples sit at room temperature while you make the crust and the topping

  3. Mix the flour with the salt

    Then cut the cold butter into smaller pieces so you can use a pastry blender to press and mix together. Be careful not to over work the dough which will make it tough.

  4. Once the flour mixture looks like meal you can start adding the ice water one spoon at a time

    Mix in the first TBS and mix a little bit then add the second one and see how the dough is starting to hold together. If it is still really dry you will need more water.

    The trick is to get it just barely where you can pull it together and then roll it out.

    I usually roll it out on a heavily floured wooden cutting board. If you have a marble board, even better.
  5. Limit the handling of the dough as much as possible as too much handling will produce a tough crust.

    Be sure to pre-heat the oven to 350℉.

    I used to bake it at 450℉ for the first 15 mins. but I've been baking it for years at 350℉ and it comes out just fine and doesn't burn.

  6. Put the apple filling into the crust

  7. Assemble the topping

    Put the flour, sugar and butter in a bowl and use that pastry blender to break it up. (the butter should be cold so it takes a little elbow grease to get it mixed together)

    You can cut the butter into pieces to make it a little easier and quicker.

     

    If you have enough apples in the filling it should be higher than the top of the 9" pie pan as it will shrink down during and after baking.
  8. It's a little tricky but just do your best to put the topping on making sure to cover the apples fully.

    Put the pie on a sheet pan before putting it in the oven as it tends to drip and you don't want that on the bottom of your oven.

  9. Bake at 350℉ for approximately 1 hour or a little more. When it is bubbling over it is done.

Note

1. Kecap Manis (sometimes called Ketjap Manis) is an Indonesian sweet soy sauce that is thicker than other soy sauces. Sometimes just labelled as "sweet soy sauce".

Also easy to make your own! Just combine 1/4 cup ordinary soy sauce (I use Kikkoman) and 1/4 cup brown sugar over medium heat. Bring to a simmer and reduce until it becomes a maple syrup consistency. It will thicken more when it cools.

2. Chilli - I use 2 birds eye or Thai red chillies, adds a mild warmth, doesn't make it spicy. Adjust to taste. Chilli paste can also be used instead - add it when you add the rice.

Still tasty WITHOUT shrimp paste. SUB with more kecap mans OR 1 tbsp fish sauce!

3. Storage - as with all fried rice, it keeps great for a day or two in the fridge then I find it gets a bit dry. Salvage it with a sprinkle of water then microwave it - makes it all steamy and moist again! Do the same if you freeze it.

4. Nutrition per serving including egg.

Keywords: delicious, homemade, apple pie
Did you make this recipe?
Recipe Card powered by WP Delicious
Sally Cevasco
Sally Cevasco

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *